Followers

Listening to/reading/watching

  • Spooks, Heroes and Little Dorrit
  • The Ascent of Money
  • Fountains of Wayne, Dusty Springfield, Nickleback, Talking Heads

Cluster Map

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

Libel

The thorny topic of libel is once again hovering like a dark cloud over the blogsphere.

What is it? How does it happen? And how likely is it that one day someone will sue you for something that you say in a blog?

What follows is a short introduction to the concept and is in no way intended as a subsitute for proper legal advice from your own lawyer.

Libel is a written statement that is defamatory. The publication of a libelous statement entitles the person who has been libelled to damages without having to prove that they have suffered any actual financial loss as a result of the libel. This is different from slander, or spoken defamation which (other than a few specific cases such as impuing someone's professional reputation or the chastity of a woman) requires a real financial loss to have occured before the right to damages arises.


So what's defamatory? "A statement intended to lower the stading of a person, or persons in the sight of right thinking people."

And which statement amounts to more than "vulgar abuse"

So "Lippy is a fat cow" is not defamatory it is mere vulgar abuse.
"Lippy is a crap lawyer and I wouldn't trust her as far as I could spit" is a libellous statement and actionable.

Let's get a grip on reality here - libel cases are prohibitivley expensive. £85,000 for costs to trial is not a top end quote. It is to put no fine a point on it, a rich man's hobby. And there is no legal aid available for cases to be taken in either libel or slander and frankly quite right too. If that became a bottomless pit of public money for defamation lawyers I'd be first at the front of the queue to protest against it.

Libel damages are ridiculsously high in comparison to personal injury damages for one reason - personal injury cases are heard by a judge alone, and he works from a price list for the damage caused - e.g. broken arm - £2000.

Libel cases are the only remaining civil cases which are heard by a jury - and the jury also sets the level of damages. So they tend to be more "american" than is common in the rest of the UK jurisdiction - think up your own examples of people in the public eye who have been given far too much money for being referred to as a too specific type of twat.

In conclusion - if you slag off your ex in a blog can he sue you for libel. Yes. Is he likely to sue you for libel? Unless he is a bored millionaire with a chip on his shoulder who wants, for reasons of his own to put you in the bankruptcy court - No.

8 comments:

Tickersoid said...

Is there a case for doing away with it all together?

Andrea said...

I'm not entirely sure. I am to some extent relieved that mad clients can't slag me off to all and sundry without the spectre of libel action hanging over them.

Tickersoid said...

I could understand wanting redress if I wrote,

"Lippy is a poor lawyer because she almost always fails to see critical legal opportunities for her clients."

However, If I wrote,

"Lippy is a crap lawyer and I wouldn't trust her as far as I could spit"

Wouldn't that just be my opinion and therefore not libelous?

Andrea said...

Opinions are as likely to be libelous as any other statement. And aren't you just saying exactly the same thing - just slightly more politley in one case than the other?

Frobisher said...

Lippy wanks off stray dogs

Would that be libelous?

BEAST said...

***looking around for poor people to slag off ****

Thats just plain rude Mr Frobisher and likely to have you thrown out of the WI

Andrea said...

Good question frobes - might well not be as it's may be vulgar abuse. Bizarre and twisted vulgar abuse but vulgar abuse all the same.

Beastie - oh bless him, that WI cake stall in the market is his social life line, you couldn't be so cruel!

Tickersoid said...

In that case, "Lippy is a superb lawyer and clearly a credit to her profession."

About Me

My photo
A blog about being middle aged, in England in 2013